218 – How Can Therapists Compete With VC-Backed Mental Health Companies?

by | Oct 26, 2026 | Podcast

Hit play for a preview, or open in Spotify for the full episode.

In this episode of the Private Practice Elevation Podcast, you'll learn how an independent practice can hold its own against the venture-funded therapy platforms crowding the top of Google.

Many therapists feel squeezed right now.

Headway just announced a $9.99 fee on every session with a new client it sends you. The big platforms have the budgets, the content teams, and the search rankings.

And the website that brought in steady inquiries a couple of years ago may have gone quiet.

Here's the good news.

A therapist starting from scratch needs 15 to 20 clients, and most of Jamie's clients only need 5 to 7 more.

You can win those clients with the things the big platforms can't give their providers: your personality, your expertise, and a website where people can picture working with you.

Today Daniel is talking to Jamie Reutershan, founder of Therapist Digital Marketing. Jamie spent 9 years at Google in New York, including 3 at Waze, then ran marketing for a portfolio of 5 brands.

In 2022 a family friend asked for help marketing his group practice in New York City. The referrals kept coming, and Jamie now works full time on websites and Google Ads for therapists. His motto for this moment: bully your bullies back.

This Episode Answers…

How much will Headway's new client fee cost therapists?

Headway's new fee is $9.99 per session for every new client it sends a therapist, for as long as that client stays. Jamie ran the numbers using Headway's own newsroom posts, press releases, and job listings.

Headway reports about 1.5 million appointments per month in 2026, or 18 million a year, and it grew 60% last year. If that pace slows to 50%, that's 27 million appointments in 2027. If 20% of those are with new clients at about $10 each, Jamie estimates Headway takes roughly $54 million out of therapists' pockets next year.

He sees it as the standard tech playbook: build a platform, get providers and customers on it, then grow profit by taking a bigger cut from providers. His advice is to pull back from it where you can.

If you're new and need income coming in, there's no shame in using it. Just expect a less even relationship than before.

How do you know if your therapy website is good enough?

Check your conversion rate. Take the number of inquiries from the last 90 days and divide it by the number of website visitors over the same 90 days.

Jamie likes to see 3% to 5%, sometimes 6%. The average across the internet is about 1%, Therapist sites should beat it. People looking for a therapist arrive ready to act.

If you're below that, fix the site before paying for more traffic. Write the homepage last, as a summary that sends people to your specialty pages and your About page. Put a photo of yourself above the fold.

Give every specialty its own full page. And spend real time on your About page: in Jamie's data, it's always the 2nd or 3rd most visited page on a therapist's website.

Where does a private practice have the edge over the big platforms?

Connection. Platforms give therapists a 500-character bio, a photo or two, and the same boxes to check as everyone else, so every profile starts to look alike. Your own website has no such limits.

Search habits are changing too.

At a recent Google event Jamie attended, the message was that people now decide faster. AI tools speed up their research. Someone might ask ChatGPT or Claude what's going on with them and what kind of therapy could help, then go to Google and search "EMDR therapist New York City." By then they know what they want. Your site has to show them you're good at this and that they'd feel at ease with you.

One of Jamie's clients wrote this on her site: "Cursing is a valid form of communication. Therapy with me can be on your couch with a snack in your pajamas."

AI won't write that line for you. Language models predict the most likely next word, so their copy lands in the middle and sounds like everyone else. Jamie and Daniel both use AI to review and audit copy, and they keep the writing itself human.

Other Key Takeaways:

  • Psychology Today now mostly sends people to your website. Jamie cited one analysis where 15% of profile visitors clicked through to the therapist's site and 5% emailed directly.
  • Jamie cited a Herd analysis of therapists: those using 3 channels to bring people to their website were beating the average.
  • Google Ads can target by state (useful for licensure), by what people search for, and, for cash-pay practices, by household income.
  • Social media is free but slow. Someone may follow you for months before reaching out, though they're usually ready to start when they do.
  • Paid traffic shows you where a weak website loses people. Jamie turns down ad clients whose websites aren't ready yet.
  • Daniel's team uses AI for coding efficiencies and for SEO articles built on carefully refined inputs. Website copy is 100% human written.
  • Google will spend as much money as you give it. Bringing in someone who knows ads usually costs less than learning it all yourself.

Links mentioned in this episode:

Therapist Digital Marketing: therapistdigitalmarketing.com

Jamie's free guide: Therapist Niche Performance Guide

Jamie's newsletter: Therapist Marketing Newsletter

Jamie's website templates for therapists and Google Ads for therapists

Ready to reach more of your ideal clients? Book a free call: privatepracticeelevation.com/kickoff

Watch The Video:

This Episode Is Brought To You By The Following Sponsors:

Zanda

Zanda practice management software is excited to partner with Private Practice Elevation Podcast to support practitioners with simple, secure tools that reduce admin and strengthen practice operations. Together, we’re helping practitioners spend less time on paperwork and more time with clients.

If you’re ready to spend less time on admin and more time with clients, visit zandahealth.com to start your free trial.

Alma

Alma is on a mission to simplify access to high-quality, affordable mental health care by giving providers the tools they need to build thriving in-network private practices. When providers join Alma, they gain access to insurance support, teletherapy software, client referrals, automated billing and scheduling tools, and a vibrant community of clinicians who come together for education, training, and events.

Learn more about building a thriving private practice with Alma at helloalma.com/elevation.

About Jamie Reutershan

Jamie Reutershan

Jamie Reutershan is the founder of Therapist Digital Marketing, where he helps therapists and group practices to get more clients. Before starting TDM, he spent nine years at Google NYC and has worked in digital marketing for over 14 years.

Since 2021, he’s worked with 200+ therapists on everything from websites and Google Ads to figure out what actually makes someone choose one therapist over another. His approach is pretty simple: use the data, lead with humanity, and make it easy for the right clients to see themselves working with you.

The goal is to give independent practices access to the kind of marketing strategy and techniques the bigger, more well funded companies have.

About Daniel Fava

Daniel Fava

Daniel Fava is the owner and founder of Private Practice Elevation, a website and SEO agency focused on helping private practice owners create websites that increase their online visibility and attract more clients. Private Practice Elevation offers web design services, SEO (search engine optimization), and WordPress support to help private practice owners grow their businesses through online marketing.

Daniel lives in Atlanta, GA with his wife Liz, and two energetic boys. When he’s not working he enjoys hiking by the river, watching hockey, and enjoying a dram of bourbon.

Grow your private practice with a new website strategy.

Get more traffic. Get more clients. Scale your practice.

 

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This